8 Chicken Pot Pie Recipes for Cold Nights

When cold weather settles in and you’re craving something warm and filling, few dishes deliver comfort quite like chicken pot pie. There’s something deeply satisfying about cracking through a flaky, golden crust to reveal tender chicken swimming in creamy sauce with vegetables. It’s the kind of meal that makes you want to curl up on the couch with a bowl and forget about the chill outside.

Chicken pot pie has been warming bellies for centuries, evolving from simple meat pies into the beloved comfort food we know today. The beauty of this dish lies in its versatility—you can make it as traditional or creative as you like. Whether you’re feeding a crowd or just looking for leftovers to enjoy throughout the week, there’s a chicken pot pie variation that’ll fit your needs.

We’ve gathered eight different takes on this classic dish, each bringing something special to the table. From quick weeknight versions to slow-cooked weekend projects, these recipes prove that chicken pot pie isn’t just one thing—it’s a whole world of cozy possibilities.

1. Classic Double-Crust Chicken Pot Pie

Save It

This is the one that probably comes to mind when you think of chicken pot pie. A buttery bottom crust holds a rich, creamy filling loaded with chicken and vegetables, all topped with another layer of flaky pastry. It’s the gold standard for a reason.

What Makes It Stand Out

The secret to a truly excellent classic pot pie is in the sauce. A proper roux made from butter and flour creates that silky gravy that coats every piece of chicken and vegetable. Chicken broth and milk work together to give you a sauce that’s rich but not heavy. The double crust means every bite has that satisfying pastry crunch alongside the creamy filling.

Essential Components

• All-butter pie crust for the flakiest texture
• Homemade sauce from butter, flour, broth, and milk
• Frozen peas and carrots for convenience and perfect texture
• Rotisserie chicken to save time on prep

The filling goes into the pie warm, which means your bottom crust cooks evenly without getting soggy. Cutting vents in the top crust isn’t just decorative—it lets steam escape so your pie doesn’t get watery. Brush that top crust with beaten egg for a gorgeous golden-brown finish that looks like it came from a bakery.

2. Chicken Pot Pie with Mushrooms and Celery

Save It

Here’s a twist on tradition that swaps out the usual peas and corn for mushrooms and celery. The result? A pot pie that tastes more sophisticated, with deeper umami flavors and a satisfying crunch from the celery.

Why It’s Worth Trying

Mushrooms bring an earthy richness that pairs beautifully with chicken. Baby bella mushrooms work wonderfully here, though white button mushrooms do the job too. The celery adds textural contrast—when you cook it briefly before baking, it stays just crisp enough to notice. Together, these vegetables create a filling that reminds you of creamy chicken noodle soup tucked inside pastry.

How to Build the Filling

Start by sautéing diced onion, chopped celery, sliced carrots, and roughly chopped mushrooms in butter. You’ll cook them just until the onions start releasing their juices—about eight minutes. Add minced garlic along with dried thyme and rosemary for aromatic depth.

The vegetables shouldn’t get mushy during this step. You want them to retain some texture since they’ll continue cooking in the oven. Once you’ve made your creamy sauce and stirred in the chicken, the filling is ready to nestle into your pie crust.

Pro tip: Don’t skip the egg wash on top—it transforms a pale crust into a showstopper.

3. Easy Skillet Chicken Pot Pie

Save It

When you need comfort food but don’t have hours to spare, this skillet version delivers all the flavor with a fraction of the work. Everything cooks in one pan, and you’ll skip the bottom crust entirely.

What Makes It Quick

Instead of fussing with rolling out two pie crusts, you’ll simply top your skillet with a single crust. Some versions use store-bought biscuits or puff pastry, which makes things even faster. The filling cooks right in your skillet, then you either lay the crust on top and bake, or you can serve the filling in bowls with the baked crust on the side.

Streamlined Ingredients

• Pre-cooked chicken (rotisserie or leftovers)
• Store-bought pie crust or refrigerated biscuits
• Frozen mixed vegetables
• Quick roux sauce made in the same pan

This version works brilliantly for weeknights when everyone’s hungry and patience is thin. You’ll have dinner on the table in about 45 minutes from start to finish. The best part? Fewer dishes to wash means more time enjoying that second helping.

Fun fact: Serving this family-style straight from the skillet makes it feel casual and inviting.

4. Creamy Chicken Pot Pie with Biscuit Topping

Save It

Swap that traditional pastry crust for fluffy, buttery biscuits and you’ve got yourself a whole new experience. The biscuits bake right on top of the filling, soaking up just enough of that creamy sauce to become irresistible.

Why Biscuits Work So Well

Biscuits bring a lighter, fluffier texture compared to pie crust. As they bake, their bottoms get slightly soggy from the filling while their tops turn golden and crisp. You get the satisfaction of tearing into a warm biscuit that’s already flavored by the chicken and gravy below.

Building This Version

Make your filling as you would for any pot pie—chicken, vegetables, creamy sauce—then transfer it to a baking dish. Drop rounds of biscuit dough on top, spacing them slightly apart. Some people use homemade biscuit dough, while others reach for the convenience of refrigerated biscuits. Either way works beautifully.

The biscuits puff up as they bake, creating peaks and valleys that catch extra sauce. Brush them with melted butter before baking for extra richness. This version is especially beloved by folks who think the filling is the best part and want more of it compared to crust.

5. Individual Mini Chicken Pot Pies

Save It

These personal-sized pot pies make portion control easy and add a special touch to dinner. Everyone gets their own little pie, complete with a perfectly golden crust and steaming filling inside.

What Makes Them Special

Mini pot pies feel like a treat. There’s something about having your own individual serving that makes the meal feel more special, even if you’re just eating in front of the TV. They’re also practical—you can freeze extras and bake them one at a time when the craving hits.

How to Assemble Them

You’ll need ramekins, small pie dishes, or even large muffin tins. Line each vessel with pie crust, fill it with your chicken mixture, then top with another round of crust. Cut a small vent in each top to let steam escape.

• Ramekins give you deeper pies with more filling
• Muffin tins create cute, handheld portions
• Small pie dishes offer traditional presentation

Baking time is shorter for mini pies since they’re smaller—usually 25 to 35 minutes does the trick. They’re perfect for dinner parties where you want to impress, or for meal prep when you want individual servings ready to reheat throughout the week.

6. Slow Cooker Chicken Pot Pie

Save It

Let your slow cooker do most of the work with this hands-off version. The filling cooks low and slow, developing deep flavors while you go about your day. You’ll add the crust element at the end.

The Slow Cooker Advantage

Cooking chicken pot pie filling in a slow cooker means the chicken becomes incredibly tender and the flavors meld beautifully. You can start it in the morning and come home to a house that smells amazing. The sauce thickens as it cooks, becoming luxuriously creamy without any fussing.

Two Ways to Finish It

Some folks prefer to make biscuits or pastry separately and serve them alongside the filling. Others transfer the cooked filling to a baking dish, top it with crust, and bake just long enough to brown the pastry—about 20 minutes.

The slow cooker method works especially well when you’re using tougher cuts of chicken or want to cook chicken breasts from frozen. The long, gentle heat ensures everything comes out tender. Stir in a bit of heavy cream at the end if you want extra richness, or keep it lighter with just milk in the sauce.

Pro tip: Thicken the sauce at the end by mixing cornstarch with cold water before stirring it in.

7. Chicken Pot Pie Soup

Save It

Sometimes you want all the flavors of chicken pot pie without the commitment of making pastry. This soup version gives you that creamy, comforting filling in a bowl, with optional crispy pastry strips for dipping.

Why Soup Makes Sense

Soup is easier to make in large batches, reheats beautifully, and lets you adjust the thickness to your preference. You can make it brothier for sipping or thicker to eat with a spoon. The flavors are identical to traditional pot pie—you’re just skipping the crust work.

How to Serve It

The filling is essentially pot pie filling with extra broth added. Make it as you normally would, but use more chicken stock to create a soup consistency. Ladle it into bowls and top with any of these:

• Crumbled puff pastry pieces
• Oyster crackers
• Homemade croutons
• Strips of pie crust baked until crispy

This version is wonderful when you’re serving a crowd and don’t want to worry about slicing and plating individual pieces. Set out a big pot of soup, a basket of pastry strips, and let everyone serve themselves. It’s casual, cozy, and feeds a bunch without breaking a sweat.

8. Lighter Chicken Pot Pie with Phyllo Crust

Save It

For those watching calories but unwilling to give up pot pie entirely, phyllo dough offers a solution. It creates a crispy, flaky topping with significantly less butter and fewer calories than traditional pie crust.

What Phyllo Brings to the Table

Phyllo dough comes in paper-thin sheets that you brush with melted butter and layer on top of your filling. As it bakes, those layers puff up and become incredibly crispy. You’ll get that satisfying crunch without the heaviness of regular pastry.

Making It Work

Use your favorite pot pie filling—you don’t need to change anything about it. Transfer the filling to a baking dish, then layer about six sheets of phyllo on top, brushing each with butter. Tuck the edges down into the dish or let them get crispy and golden around the rim.

The phyllo bakes quickly, so keep an eye on it. Once it’s golden brown (usually 25 to 30 minutes), your lighter pot pie is ready. Some people also make individual versions by cutting phyllo into rounds and placing them in muffin tins with filling.

Keep in mind: Phyllo dries out fast, so keep unused sheets covered with a damp towel while you work.

Wrapping Up

Save It

Chicken pot pie proves that comfort food doesn’t have to be boring. Whether you stick with a classic double crust or experiment with biscuits, phyllo, or even soup form, you’re guaranteed a warm, satisfying meal that takes the edge off any cold night. The beauty of these recipes is their flexibility—swap vegetables, use what you have on hand, and make them your own.

Don’t be afraid to prep components ahead of time. Cook your filling, refrigerate it, and add the crust when you’re ready to bake. Many of these freeze beautifully too, which means you can make a double batch and stash extras for those nights when cooking feels impossible. However you make it, chicken pot pie remains one of those meals that just makes everything feel a little bit better.