Sugar Apple Vs Soursop: Which Is More Healthier?

Sugar apples and soursops are two tropical fruits that are closely related but have distinct differences when it comes to taste, texture and nutritional profile. With their sweet custard-like flesh and array of health benefits, both fruits have become increasingly popular in recent years. But which one is ultimately healthier? Let’s compare sugar apples and soursops side-by-side.

Sugar Apple

Sugar Apple Vs Soursop, FruitoNix

Also known as sweetsop or custard apple, the sugar apple is the fruit of Annona squamosa, a small, tropical, deciduous tree. Native to the tropical region of the Americas and West Indies, sugar apples are typically found in areas like Mexico, Brazil, Peru and India.

The exterior of the fruit resembles a pinecone with a green, bumpy, scaly or segmented skin. Inside, it has a creamy white flesh with a sweet, delicious flavor reminiscent of vanilla custard. The texture is soft and melt-in-your-mouth. Throughout the flesh, small, edible black seeds can be found.

Sugar apples contain vitamin C, vitamin B6 and iron. A 100-gram serving provides about 75 calories and is particularly high in carbohydrates from natural sugars. The fruit contains both glucose and fructose in nearly equal amounts. With its sweet, custardy interior, it’s no surprise this fruit often becomes the star ingredient in ice creams, smoothies and other desserts.

What Is Soursop?

Sugar Apple Vs Soursop, FruitoNix

Soursop, also called guanábana, is the fruit of Annona muricata, a broadleaf, flowering, evergreen tree native to Mexico, Cuba, Central America, the Caribbean and northern South America. Today it is widely grown throughout the tropics for its edible fruit.

The exterior of the soursop is typically green with soft spines. Weighing up to 15 pounds, it’s considerably larger than the sugar apple. Cutting open the fruit reveals a tangy, creamy white flesh containing an abundance of seeds. The flavor is often described as a tropical combination of strawberry, pineapple and citrus.

Soursop is packed full of vitamin C – a single serving supplies over 250% of your daily needs. Additionally, it contains significant amounts of thiamin, riboflavin, vitamin B6, calcium, iron and phosphorus. Due to its tart, acidic taste, soursop is commonly used in beverages, ice creams and smoothies rather than eaten raw.

Distinguishing Taste and Textures

While both feature custard-like flesh, there are stark differences when it comes to flavor. Sugar apples offer a sweetness akin to vanilla pudding with a subtle background of tropical flavors. Soursops, on the other hand, provide a bold tang that embodies citrus fruits like pineapple and strawberry.

The flesh of the sugar apple is more dry and crumbly, similar to avocado. Soursop flesh has a slimier, almost stringy texture comparable to a banana. While both contain seeds, soursop seeds are significantly larger in size and tougher than the small, unobtrusive seeds found in sugar apples.

Potential Health Benefits

Rich in antioxidants, both sugar apple and soursop have been studied for their potential medicinal properties.

Research indicates that compounds in soursop may be naturally cytotoxic to cancer cells. Additional studies suggest soursop may provide anti-inflammatory, anti-parasitic, anticonvulsant and sedative effects.

Meanwhile, sugar apples contain tannins and acetogenins that may help fight viruses, bacteria, parasites and tumors. The seeds are considered to have anthelmintic properties that expel parasitic worms from the body. However, more research is needed to fully verify these potential benefits in humans.

Which Is More Nutritious?

When comparing these two tropical fruits, soursop is the clear winner nutritionally. Ounce for ounce, it contains significantly higher amounts of vitamins, minerals and antioxidants.

A 100-gram serving of soursop provides:

  • Vitamin C: 248% Daily Value
  • Thiamin: 8% DV
  • Iron: 8% DV

Compared to sugar apple, which supplies just:

  • Vitamin C: 14% DV
  • Vitamin B6: 8% DV
  • Iron: 5% DV

Thanks to its stellar vitamin C content, soursop is extra powerful for immune health. It also offers a diverse range of B vitamins, electrolyte minerals like potassium and antioxidants like acetogenins.

Sugar Apple vs. Soursop: Which Should You Choose?

When it comes to nutritional value, soursop wins over sugar apple. However, food choices involve personal preferences too. Due to its sweetness, sugar apple may be more appealing for eating raw, especially for those with a sweet tooth. Meanwhile, soursop’s tangy tartness lends itself well to smoothies, juices and ice creams.

Both fruits can be highly perishable and difficult to find fresh. Opt for frozen, canned or dried versions for easy use anytime. Whip up sugar apple custard or vanilla-soursop ice cream for a tropical treat.

While the verdict is still out regarding their medicinal properties, adding either fruit to your diet provides vitamin C, antioxidants and a delicious new flavor. However, based solely on nutrition, soursop takes the trophy as the healthier choice between these exotic fruits.

With their creamy textures and enticing aromas, sugar apples and soursops offer a tasty way to add variety to your diet. Bring a taste of the tropics to your kitchen by trying both and seeing which you prefer.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button